Breaking News: Kalani Sitake Stays at BYU! After intense speculation and talks with Penn State, BYU's head coach, Kalani Sitake, has decided to remain with the Cougars. This is a huge win for BYU, and a testament to Sitake's commitment to the program.
Sitake and BYU have agreed on a new contract, as reported by ESPN, which is described as "lucrative." This deal will keep the former Cougar fullback in royal blue, despite Penn State reportedly making him their top coaching target. This announcement comes just before BYU's Big 12 championship game against No. 5 Texas Tech.
BYU's athletic director, Brian Santiago, expressed his excitement, stating that Sitake is a proven leader and that they are grateful he is choosing BYU. He emphasized Sitake's role in building a championship program and the positive momentum he brings. While the specifics of the new deal haven't been released, sources indicate significant investments for Sitake's assistants, including offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick and defensive coordinator Jay Hill, as well as resources for name, image, and likeness (NIL) initiatives within the program.
But here's where it gets controversial... Is the investment worth it? BYU defensive back Evan Johnson certainly thinks so, calling Sitake the "best coach in the nation." The program's financial backing, supported by donors like Nutricost CEO Min Kim and Crumbl CEO Jason McGowan, certainly helps.
Under Sitake's leadership, the Cougars have achieved an impressive 83-44 record over the past decade. This includes an 11-1 season in 2025 and a strong 8-1 record in Big 12 play. The team has also made seven bowl appearances and boasts a 4-3 postseason record. Since 2020, Sitake's 56-19 record places him among the top coaching ranks in the Football Bowl Subdivision.
Sitake is also a strong advocate for BYU and its sponsoring institution, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. He has successfully navigated the complexities of NIL and the transfer portal, cultivating a unique culture within the BYU locker room, despite what is believed to be one of the lowest-paid coaching staffs in the Big 12.
Sitake expressed his gratitude for the support he's received, emphasizing the stability and future of BYU football. This decision also helps secure the future for the Cougars, who currently have the No. 20-ranked 2026 recruiting class. This class includes highly-rated players like quarterback Ryder Lyons and in-state talents like Bott Mulitalo, Brock Harris, Adam Bywater, and Lopeti "Juni" Moala.
And this is the part most people miss... The early signing period begins soon, which adds another layer of importance to this announcement.
What do you think? Do you agree with the decision? Share your thoughts in the comments below! What impact will this have on BYU's future in the Big 12?
